Strategy
Wardley's doctrine: the 40 principles explained
Doctrine is a set of 40 universal principles for strategic success, focused on situational awareness, user needs and adaptability.
Updated
Wardley Mapping Doctrine is a set of 40 universal principles for strategic success, focusing on situational awareness, user needs, and adaptability in dynamic environments.
Doctrine emphasizes small, iterative steps, efficiency, and removing bias. It provides a framework for organizations to navigate and compete effectively by focusing on transparency, appropriate methodologies, embracing failure, and empowering teams.
What is Doctrine?
Doctrine represents a comprehensive set of best practices that work in every situation, for every organization. These principles are universally applicable - no reasonable person can argue that principles like "Know your users" or "Challenge assumptions" should be ignored.
Why "Doctrine" Instead of "Principles"?
The word "Doctrine" originates from Sun Tzu's "Art of War" translation and has been adapted by Simon Wardley for modern strategy. For mappers, Doctrine is not a scary word but a set of universally applicable principles that work in every situation, for every organization.
Think of it: Can any reasonable person argue that principles such as 'Know your users' or 'Challenge assumptions' should be ignored? It just does not make sense. That makes them universally applicable.
Every single organization should have these principles covered. Unfortunately, they often don't because they are not aware this is something they should manage.
Simon Wardley identified forty universal principles, and for many organizations, this is a breakthrough because they can finally talk about their internal processes.
The Four Phases of Doctrine
Doctrine principles are organized into four phases, each building upon the previous:
Phase I: Foundation Principles
Focus: Communication, Development, Operation, Learning
Key Principles:
- Common LanguageEffective collaboration requires a shared language
- Challenge AssumptionsAllow people to ask questions and challenge assumptions
- Understand What Is Being ConsideredFocus on awareness to improve performance
- Know Your UsersAny value we create is through meeting the needs of others
- Focus on User NeedsEssential part of mapping is the anchor of user needs
- Remove Bias and DuplicationEliminate custom-built commodities and redundant systems
- Use Appropriate MethodsAvoid one-size-fits-all approaches
- Know the DetailsUse small teams and break large landscapes into small contracts
- Bias Towards DataProvide consistent measurement against outcomes
- Bias Towards OpenShare maps and allow others to challenge assumptions
Phase II: Building Capability
Focus: Communication, Development, Operation, Learning, Leading, Structure
Key Principles:
- Focus on the OutcomeFocus on what you are trying to achieve
- Think Fast, Inexpensive, Restrained and Elegant (FIRE)Act quickly, use inexpensive components
- Manage FailureEvery system has risks - understand failure modes
- Effectiveness Over EfficiencyOptimizing is important but don't forget the big picture
- Bias Towards ActionDoing is the ultimate way of learning
- Move FastAn imperfect plan executed today is better than a perfect one tomorrow
- Strategy Is IterativeFocus on iterative, adaptable strategies
- Think Small TeamsBreak everything into small teams
- Distribute Power and Decision MakingDistribute power to those closest to decision-making
- Think Aptitude and AttitudeCombine skills with cultural approaches
Phase III: Optimization
Focus: Operation, Learning, Leading, Structure
Key Principles:
- Optimise FlowRemove bottlenecks and improve throughput
- Do Better With LessBias towards continual improvement
- Set Exceptional StandardsDon't settle for as good as competitors
- Bias Towards the NewHave a bias towards the new, be curious
- Commit to the DirectionOnce you've set a direction, commit to it
- Be the OwnerTake responsibility for your environment and actions
- Inspire OthersThink small for actions, big for inspiration
- Embrace UncertaintyAvoid believing you can plan the future
- Be HumbleListen, be selfless, show fortitude
- Seek the BestFind and nurture the best people
- Provide Purpose, Mastery & AutonomyEach team should be autonomous
Phase IV: Advanced Strategy
Focus: Learning, Leading, Structure
Key Principles:
- Listen to Your EcosystemEcosystems offer various exploitation methods
- Exploit The LandscapeUse the landscape to your advantage
- There Is No CoreEverything is transient
- There Is No Single CultureCultivate multiple cultures within the organization
- Design for Constant EvolutionTeams may be semi-permanent, but their work evolves
How to Use Doctrine
There are two primary ways to use doctrine:
1. Improving Your Operations
Your team should go through the list of principles and evaluate how well your organization is performing in each area. It's useful to separate management into a different group and check whether perspectives are aligned.
Evaluation Method:
- Red - Poor
- Green - Good
- Amber - Improvement possible
- White - No data
The diagnosis part remains the same. To implement changes, realize it will take time. Forty doctrine principles is a lot, and trying to introduce all of them in one go would end in an inevitable crash. That's why the doctrine principles are split into four phases.
2. Evaluating Competitors
Use doctrine to assess your competitors' ability to respond to market changes. The expectations are that organizations that are poor at doctrine are poor in business because they cannot react to market changes even if their existing business looks good.
Key Insights
Universal Applicability
- Every organization should have these principles covered
- They work in every situation, for every organization
- No reasonable person can argue against core principles like "Know your users"
Implementation Strategy
- Start with Phase I, then Phase II, then Phase III, and finally Phase IV
- Later phases require earlier phases to work
- Don't try to implement all 40 principles at once
Value of Discussion
- There is a lot of value in the discussion that emerges while evaluating doctrine
- Different perspectives between management and teams can reveal important insights
- The evaluation process itself creates awareness and alignment
Strategic Implications
Competitive Advantage
Organizations with strong doctrine execution are more dangerous competitors and better places to work. They can react to market changes effectively and maintain competitive advantage.
Risk Management
Poor doctrine execution creates vulnerability - organizations cannot react to market changes even if their existing business looks good.
Organizational Health
Doctrine provides a framework for organizations to finally talk about their internal processes in a structured way, leading to improved alignment and effectiveness.
Application to Wardley Mapping
When mapping doctrine:
- Map current stateWhere is your organization on each principle?
- Identify gapsWhich principles are poorly implemented?
- Prioritize improvementsFocus on Phase I principles first
- Track progressUse the color-coded evaluation system
- Align teamsEnsure management and operational teams have aligned perspectives
Key Principles for Success
- Start with Phase I - Build the foundation before moving to advanced principles
- Evaluate honestly - Use the color system to assess current state
- Focus on discussion - The evaluation process creates value through alignment
- Implement gradually - Don't try to change everything at once
- Measure progress - Track improvements over time
Conclusion
Doctrine provides a comprehensive framework for organizational success through 40 universal principles. By systematically evaluating and implementing these principles across four phases, organizations can improve their ability to compete, adapt, and succeed in dynamic environments.
The key is to start with the foundation principles, build capability gradually, and use the evaluation process to create alignment and awareness across the organization.
Doctrine provides the foundation for strategic success. Learn more about value chains, evolution stages, and the ILC model to understand how doctrine fits into broader strategic thinking.
Want to find where your organisation breaks these principles? The applied workshop works through it with your team.